Loading live prices…

Market data by TradingView

Home / Articles

CopperStocks original

Board finds Teck used ineligible workers at Highland Valley

British Columbia's Labour Relations Board has ordered Teck Resources (TSX: TECK.A, TECK.B; NYSE: TECK) to stop using ineligible replacement workers at its struck Highland Valley Copper mine, ruling that the operator broke the province's replacement-worker ban four times. It refused the union's request for an order letting its representatives into the mine to monitor the work.

In a decision dated Nov. 13, Vice-Chair Paul Todd declared that the employer breached sections 6(3)(e) and 68(1) of the Labour Relations Code by using ineligible replacement workers to perform bargaining-unit work, and ordered it to cease and desist. He also declined to appoint a special investigating officer or to award the damages sought by United Steelworkers Local 7619. The employer named in the case is Teck Highland Valley Copper Partnership, which operates the mine about 17 kilometres west of Logan Lake.

The union's application alleged seven breaches. Pre-hearing discussions narrowed that to five, which Todd heard in an expedited hearing from Nov. 3 to 6. He upheld four.

Two of the findings concern employees promoted from the bargaining unit to supervisor. Both had worked full-time supervisor hours since earlier in the year but formally left the unit on June 16 and July 24, after June 9, the date Teck says bargaining began. The union says talks started earlier; Todd did not rule on the exact date. Todd found they were engaged as supervisors only when they formally left the unit, which makes them ineligible to do bargaining-unit work during the strike.

"A bright-line approach based on the assessment of the employment status of the individual employee at the relevant date is preferable," he wrote.

Todd described the company's use of the two supervisors as "ongoing and more significant." He noted there was no allegation that Teck had tried to conceal their work, and that it had a settled intention to move them out of the unit before bargaining began, which does not indicate it hired them to defeat the strike.

Teck conceded the third breach: an employee who retired from the bargaining unit on Oct. 1 and was rehired into a role outside it helped eligible replacement workers in the instrumentation shop on two occasions. Todd found the work was done in error. The fourth was a contractor working on the mine-life extension project clearing snow from a mine road with a grader on Oct. 28. Todd found the road was maintained by bargaining-unit employees and the snow clearing was regular maintenance. He called those two breaches time-limited and isolated.

Todd found no breach on the fifth allegation, which involved a consultant listed on a public database as chief operator of the mine's potable water and wastewater treatment systems. He found the consultant never attended the site and did not perform bargaining-unit work.

Access refused

The union argued the operation stretches over many square kilometres it cannot observe from its picket lines. Todd wrote that the four breaches "do not justify such an extraordinary order," and that ordering worksite access so union representatives could monitor compliance would be "a significant departure from the Board's established approach."

He found the breaches were not egregious enough to warrant an investigating officer. On damages, he wrote that the board rarely awards them in replacement-worker cases, "particularly when it is the first violation." He noted this was the first application alleging a breach during this job action.

The bargaining unit has about 1,200 employees, according to the decision. The collective agreement expired Sept. 30, members voted in favour of a strike on Oct. 19 and the union began job action on Oct. 24.

The union's president testified about buses with blacked-out windows entering the mine and contractors obscuring logos on their trucks.

Todd wrote that "not all of the behaviour that raised the Union's suspicions necessarily means the Employer has engaged in further breaches of the Code."

By Staff Writer. Published by CopperStocks.

Nothing on CopperStocks is investment advice.